9 Questions to Ask When Hiring a Sales Tax Accountant

by Jennifer Dunn November 1, 2020

Hiring any professional can be daunting, especially when you’re not sure exactly what you need. Ask these questions to make sure you’re hiring the right sales tax accountant for your business. And when you’re ready to hire, check out our list of vetted sales tax experts!

1.) Is sales tax your main focus?

Accounting is a broad field and sales tax experts are a smaller subsection of the industry. This means that the accountant you use for your income tax may know the basics of sales tax, but not the many intricacies. Or they may know quite a lot about sales tax in the state where the operate, but not much about multi-state sales tax issues. In fact, many accountants send complicated sales tax questions to specialists.

This is why your sales tax expert may not necessarily be an “accountant.” Her or she may be a traditional CPA, but could also be an enrolled agent, sales tax attorney or other sales tax specialist.

Ask your potential sales tax accountant if sales tax is her main focus and what she would do if she ran into a knotty problem that involved many states.

2.) What background and training do you have to do this type of work?

How long has your sales tax expert worked in sales tax? Is he or she credentialed?

The CMI (which stands for “Certified Member of the Institute”) from the Institute of Professionals in Taxation (IPT) is the only specific sales tax designation. Earning the certification takes 5 years of full time sales tax experience plus a rigorous exam.

3.) Do you have experience working with clients like me?

We talk almost daily to eCommerce sellers who try to visit their hometown CPA only to be treated like a brick and mortar business. Selling online has it’s own unique set of accounting challenges, and dealing with sales tax is a big part of that.

Ask your potential tax professional if he has worked with eCommerce sellers, for how long, and how many eCommerce clients he has helped.

4.) What services are covered by your charges?

Be wary of comparing prices on a website. Instead ask your potential sales tax accountant what types of services their pricing covers. This depends on what you’re looking for. An advisor may charge you a consulting fee but leave the legwork of reporting and filing sales tax in you hands, while another sales tax expert might take the process entirely out of your hands. It all depends on your company, your budget and your expectations.

5.) Who will I actually work with?

Will you work with the owner of the company or a junior assistant? Depending on your needs and budget, this may be an important distinction.

6.) What else do you do outside of sales tax?

Does the company also deal with other aspects of state and local tax, like corporate income tax and franchise tax? This will help you determine if this is your one-stop-shop or a true specialized expert.

7.) How will we communicate?

What if you’re a phone talker but your potential sales tax expert lives for email? Or you run your business on the weekends and need someone available in off hours? It’s crucial to determine if your communication styles match up. Otherwise even the most knowledgeable and experienced sales tax professional may leave you feeling dissatisfied.

8.) Will you work with the accounting software and services I use?

This is a big one. If you’ve done all your bookkeeping on GoDaddy Online Bookkeeping and your accountant wants you to switch to Quickbooks, the learning curve may just be too high. Or, if you’re a TaxJar user (and if you’re not, why not try a 30-day free trial?) you want to make sure your accountant can work with you. Find out if your potential sales tax expert will work with your business or require you to work her way.

9.) Do you have a list of references I can talk to?

Experienced sales tax experts will have references to back up their work. Ask to talk to some references before you retain a sales tax experts’s services. And remember, the sales tax experts on this page have been vetted by TaxJar customers.

A big thanks to George Sleeman of Tax Man to You, Lauren Stinson of Windward TaxSylvia Dion, CPA and the members of Sales Tax for eCommerce Sellers Facebook group for helping come up with the questions for this post!

Did we miss any questions you should ask your potential sales tax accountant? Let us know in the comments!

2023 Sales Tax Preparedness Guide

Discover sales tax trends and changes that could impact your compliance in 2023. You’ll also find helpful information on product taxability, and how to manage hitting economic nexus thresholds in new states this shopping season.

Read now